Bug #9747
closedScan Skip Programming Issue
0%
Description
When uploading to radio or reopening a file with scan skip enabled on some channels, NOAA 11, (Channel 127 and the LAST available channel), always reverts to scan skip off.
Files
Updated by Jim Unroe about 3 years ago
- File 2022-02-11 20_17_41-CHIRP.png 2022-02-11 20_17_41-CHIRP.png added
- Status changed from New to Incomplete
Hi Scott,
I can't duplicate this error. What I did was to set all programmed channels to be skipped. Then I saved the tab to a CHIRP Radio Images (*.img). Then lastly loaded the "image" back into CHIRP. All programmed channels are still programmed to be skipped when scanning (see attached screen capture).
Would you please be more specific about how to produce this error?
Thanks,
Jim KC9HI
Updated by Scott Gregory about 3 years ago
Thanks Jim,
I've attached two screen grabs and the .img file I last saved.
When I upload to the radio, scan skip for the last channel disappears and the radio will scan NOAA11.
When I save the file and reopen it, the same thing happens. No matter what I do or how I do it, channel 127 always loses the scan skip setting.
Thanks again,
Scott Gregory
WRPI660
Updated by Scott Gregory about 3 years ago
- File scan_skip_1.jpg scan_skip_1.jpg added
Updated by Scott Gregory about 3 years ago
- File scan_skip_2.jpg scan_skip_2.jpg added
Updated by Jim Unroe about 3 years ago
Here is your file back with channel 127 set to be skipped. What does it look like when you load it into your CHIRP?
Jim KC9HI
Updated by Scott Gregory about 3 years ago
Your scan skip 2 file loads with ch 127 set to skip. If I disable skip and save the file it reloads with skip set. I disabled skip on 127 again and saved the file as skip_3. When skip_3 is opened again, it loads with skip set.
I saved skip_3 again this time changing the power value from high to low. When the file is reopened it comes back with a power level of 'Med'. It seems as though values for ch 127 are being saved with a plus one added?
Updated by Jim Unroe about 3 years ago
Scott,
My guess is that what you are missing is that with Windows, choosing a value from a drop down list does not complete the selection. You must either click onto another cell or press the [Enter] key to make the choice permanent. If this is not done, the selection and CHIRP will display the unchanged value at the next refresh. This is not necessary when using CHRIP running on Linux or macOS.
For example, if Power was set to High and you click on Low in the list and then click the [Refresh] button without first clicking on another cell or pressing the [Enter] key, the value for Power (High) will be displayed because the choice (Low) was never completed. However, if you select Low and then either clicking onto another cell or press the [Enter] key before clicking on the [Refresh] button, the new choice will have been fully selected and remain.
I would imagine that you were going down each memory row one-by-one changing the Skip setting to "S". By the nature of doing this, after choosing "S" from the drop down list you clicked on the cell below (which made the previous choice permanent) to begin working on the next memory row. This process was continued by choosing "S" and once again clicking the cell in the next row (again making the previous choice permanent). Then once you got to the last row, you chose the "S" but did not click onto another cell (to the left or above or both) or press the [Enter] key leaving the last choice not permanently set. So upon the next refresh (uploading to a radio, downloading from a radio, saving a file, loading a file, clicking the [Refresh] button, etc.), the not fully selected cell is returned back to its original (because it was not fully changed by the user) value.
One way to guarantee that a choice is always made permanent is to use the Memory Properties editor. To access the Memory Properties editor you can either click the [Properties] button at the top of the Spreadsheet Style Memory Editor or you can right-click the memory row that you want to edit and choose "Properties" from the list that appears. Once you click the [OK] button, any changes that were made in the Memory Properties editor are complete.
The Memory Properties editor also allows you to change common settings of multiple memory rows at the same time. For example, to set the Skip setting of all the "NOAA" memory rows to "S" at the same time you would do the following.
- Click memory row 117 to highlight it
- Shift-click memory row 127 to highlight memory rows 117-127
- Click the [Properties] button (alternatively right-click one of the highlighted memory rows and choose "Properties")
- Tick the box to the left of Skip to enable editing of this setting
- Change the value of Skip to "S"
- Click the [OK] button to make the change permanent on all selected memory rows.
Jim KC9HI
Updated by Scott Gregory about 3 years ago
Thanks Jim, yup, that did the trick! I swear remember clicking away but I guess I haven't been.
You da man!
Thanks again for all the help,
Scott
WRPI660
Updated by Jim Unroe about 3 years ago
- Status changed from Incomplete to Resolved
That is good news. I can remember going through the same thing back in the summer of 2012 after CHIRP added support for the Baofeng UV-5R. I've programmed quite a few radios since then. LOL
Have fun with your UV-9G (that's one I don't have yet).
Jim KC9HI
Updated by Bernhard Hailer about 3 years ago
- Status changed from Resolved to Closed